As federal, state, and local governments work to administer and deliver public services, they face a wide array of options from direct political control to broad contracts with private entities. Large shares of government services are now delivered by non-governmental organizations with many service-providers exercising substantial discretion over program operation. How does the American public view such delegation of public services to private entities? Using a survey experiment of 2,000 American adults, we find that the public does not prefer private, for-profit entities compared with bureaucratic agencies or direct legislative control. Contrary to arguments made by many politicians, respondents are less likely to view them as likely to provide high-quality or cost-effective services. While non-profit contractors receive more support than for-profit contractors, the public is most supportive of specialized government agencies. Support for specialized government agencies is also greater than for direct control by elected representatives, indicating that the public favors expertise over direct responsiveness. Taken together, these results suggest that the American public does not enthusiastically support privatization and, in fact, dislikes it.